top of page

How to balance autonomy and structure in homeschooling? Download the workbook: Freedom Levels

How Can "Freedom Levels" Revolutionize Your Homeschooling Experience?

Striking the right balance between freedom and structure has always been a challenge for homeschooling parents. While the flexibility of homeschooling is its primary appeal, maintaining a structured learning environment is equally important. Too much structure, and children may feel stifled; too much freedom, and they might become aimless. The question is: how do you ensure your child remains disciplined while relishing the freedom that homeschooling provides?

So, we've heard about this idea of "Freedom Levels" in homeschooling. What's the essence of it?

Well, imagine if homeschooling were gamified. Children earn their freedom, not through arbitrary means, but based on clear achievements. By accomplishing tasks or goals they set, they earn points. The accumulation of these points determines their freedom level in the subsequent week.

Diving Deeper: What Are "Freedom Levels"?

Imagine a system where your child has the ability to earn their freedom through their work. This isn’t about subjective judgments but tangible achievements. For instance, setting goals or completing tasks in a certain manner could earn them points. Rack up a specified number of points within a week, and voila! They level up to greater freedom in their studies for the subsequent week. Fail to do so, and they start from a foundational level, with set schedules and study environments.For instance, by setting particular academic goals or tasks (let's say task a.b.c), a child could earn x points upon completion (20 points, hypothetically). Gather 300 points within a week? They've just unlocked the highest freedom level.

What this essentially translates to is the child having the autonomy to choose:

What they work on.

When they work on it.

Where they work on it.

However, this is within the confines of the previously agreed-upon goals for that week.

But, life happens. Distractions occur. And in weeks where the child doesn't meet their target? They start at Freedom Level 1 with a predefined schedule and specific work environment (like a dedicated desk). This isn't punishment but rather a structured way to help them refocus.

Breaking It Down: What Might Freedom Levels 1, 2, & 3 Look Like?

Let's break it down:

  • Goal Setting: Your child decides they want to understand the basics of photosynthesis. They break down this task into sub-tasks: a) watch a documentary, b) read two articles, and c) write a short essay. Each sub-task, when completed to a set standard, earns them 20 points.

  • Accumulation: If they accumulate, say, 300 points from various tasks within a week, they elevate to the highest freedom level for the next week.

  • Freedom Level Achieved: At this top freedom level, they can choose what topic they wish to delve into next, decide when they'll study it, and even pick their favorite spot in the house to study from, all within the overarching goals set for the week.

  • Fallback: However, a week of distractions and missed tasks might see them drop to Freedom Level 1 the next week. Here, they have a set desk and a schedule outlined for them.

The beauty lies in its clarity. The children aren't guessing; they know the exact steps to earn their agency over their day.

Sample Freedom Levels Breakdown:

  • Freedom Level 1: You have a designated desk and a fixed schedule which you need to follow. Points required: 0-99.

  • Freedom Level 2: You can choose the sequence in which you tackle subjects, but the study location and daily schedule remain fixed. Points required: 100-199.

  • Freedom Level 3: You get to pick what you study, when you study, and your study spot. An absolute autonomy within the broader goals for the week. Points required: 200-300.

But wouldn’t children just rush through tasks to get points? How does this ensure genuine learning?

A valid concern. The system would only be as good as its design. The tasks and the associated points shouldn't just be about completion, but about understanding. The goals should challenge the child to think deeply and engage with the material. If they're just skimming through to earn points, the system's effectiveness is lost.

Negotiating Freedom Levels With Your Child

One might argue that merely implementing this isn't enough. It's essential for parents and children to co-create this system. This co-creation ensures the child is invested.

Here are some guiding questions for this negotiation:

  • How many freedom levels do we want to have?

  • What tasks or achievements are required to reach each level?

  • How many points is each task worth? Is it based on effort, completion, or mastery?

  • What freedoms are associated with each level?

  • Are there any non-negotiables in terms of study topics or hours?

  • How can we ensure that this system promotes deep learning and not just task completion?

In conclusion,

Freedom Levels offers an innovative approach to blending motivation with accountability. It's not just about "gaming the system" but fostering a genuine love for learning, coupled with a sense of responsibility. Each family can tailor it to their unique needs, but the underlying principle remains – empowering children to take charge of their educational journey.


bottom of page